Tim Pratt's Journal

Get Email Updates
Email Me

Admin Password

Remember Me

2802971 Curiosities served
Share on Facebook

A Bad Review
Previous Entry :: Next Entry

Read/Post Comments (22)

Well, Publishers Weekly hates me.

The Strange Adventures of Rangergirl Tim Pratt. Bantam, $12 paper (400p) ISBN 0-553-38338-8

Pratt (Little Gods), praised for his short fiction, stumbles in his first novel. Marzipan "Marzi" McCarty, a 20ish California art school dropout, writes quirky comics. Marzi's also the night manager–barista of Genius Loci, a Santa Cruz coffeehouse decorated by vanished muralist Garamond Ray to hold in elemental Evil. The wild adventures that Marzi concocts for her cowpunk character, Rangergirl, start coming true after her artsy friends become obsessed with freeing weird gods. When the Outlaw, a representative of everyone's worst fears, busts loose from its surreal corral, the Desert Lands, it's up to Marzi, the new artist-guardian, to save the whole shootin' match from disaster. Pratt's simplistic message, glimpsed sporadically behind clouds of neo-hippie jargon, self-consciously naughty language, outdoor sex and nasty violence, is pretentious and even a little naïve—that art can trap our fears and hold them at bay. Like too much marzipan, it all turns cloying mighty fast, pardners. (Dec.)

Ah, well. At least abuse is a form of attention.

The Locus review, coming out next month, is rather more positive, so balance is maintained in the universe.

Update: David Moles linked to a page where Michael Chabon compiled a bunch of nasty reviews of his books, "The Pull-Quotes They Neglected To Pull", and I must admit, quite irrationally, they made me feel a lot better!

Read/Post Comments (22)

Previous Entry :: Next Entry

Back to Top

Powered by JournalScape © 2001-2010 All rights reserved.
All content rights reserved by the author.